Should AI be judging our credit worthiness?
Real-world example for IB, A-Level, AP and IGCSE Economics essays: Information failure, Financial markets and banks, Market power and competition policy
What happened
An article asks whether AI should be used to judge whether someone is suitable for a mortgage, car loan or mobile phone contract.
The economics
Credit assessment involves asymmetric information: borrowers know more about their repayment ability than lenders, who rely on signals such as credit scores to screen risk. Replacing human judgement with AI scoring models can produce information failure if the models are biased by their training data, and it shapes who the credit market allocates funds to.
Evaluation
AI may cut assessment costs and speed up approvals, but opaque or biased models could exclude some borrowers from credit; the long-run outcome depends on data quality and regulation rather than the technology alone.
Practice question
Using this example, discuss how asymmetric information affects credit markets and evaluate the advantages and disadvantages of using AI for credit assessment.
Where it fits in the syllabus
- Information failure: One side of a deal knows more than the other, so the market allocates resources badly.
- Financial markets and banks: How banks, bond and stock markets fund the economy, and what swings in asset prices do.
- Market power and competition policy: When a few firms control a market they can raise prices; governments use antitrust and regulation to protect competition.
- IB Economics: Government Intervention and Market Failure, Fiscal and Monetary Policy
- A-Level Economics: Market Failure, Economic Policy, Government Microeconomic Intervention
- AP Macroeconomics: Financial Sector
- AP Microeconomics: Market Failure and the Role of Government, Monopoly, Oligopoly and Monopolistic Competition
- IGCSE Economics: Business Economics